「風立ちぬ」タバコの表現方法に日本禁煙学会が苦言 ネット「ネトウヨみたいな言い掛かり」

8月10~11日の国内映画ランキング(全国週末興行成績・興行通信社提供)で、宮崎駿監督の「風立ちぬ」が4週連続首位を守り、好調をつづけているところだが、思わぬところから"物言い"が入った。日本禁煙学会だ。

日本禁煙学会の発表した「要望書」によると、現在、日本を含む177か国以上が批准している「タバコ規制枠組み条約」の13条ではあらゆるメディアによるタバコ広告・宣伝を禁止しているため、「風立ちぬ」は「条約違反」ということになるのだという。


具体的なシーンとしては、

「教室での喫煙場面、職場で上司を含め職員の多くが喫煙している場面、高級リゾートホテルのレストラン内での喫煙場面など、数え上げれば枚挙にいとまがありません」

「特に、肺結核で伏している妻の手を握りながらの喫煙描写は問題です。夫婦間の、それも特に妻の心理を描写する目的があるとはいえ、なぜこの場面でタバコが使われなくてはならなかったのでしょうか。他の方法でも十分表現できたはずです」

「また、学生が『タバコくれ』と友人にタバコをもらう場面などは未成年者の喫煙を助長し、国内法の「未成年者喫煙禁止法」にも抵触するおそれがあります。事実、公開中のこの映画には小学生も含む多くの子どもたちが映画館に足を運んでいます。過去の出来事とはいえ、さまざまな場面での喫煙シーンがこども達に与える影響は無視できません」

等々。苦言を呈したのち、

「このお願いは貴社を誹謗中傷する目的は一切なく、貴社がますます繁栄し今後とも映画ファンが喜ぶ作品の制作に関わられることを心から希望しております。

どうぞその旨をご理解いただき、映画制作にあたってはタバコの扱いについて、特段の留意をされますことを心より要望いたします」

と結んでいる。

これについてTwitter上では

「ばっかじゃねえのw」
「これはピント外れな要望」
「時代物作品を現代の価値観で評価するのは『侍が刀を所持している描写は銃刀法違反だ!』と言ってるようなもの。つまりちょっと落ち着けと」
「風立ちぬが禁煙学会から要望出されたなら、ワンピースにも要望が行くはずではwwwww 銀魂は色んな所から要望きそうwww」

と呆れた声が噴出。同学会は"映画ファンが喜ぶ作品の制作に関わられることを心から希望しております"というが、むしろ「まったくもって的外れ。映画が泣くよ」という声が圧倒的だ。

2ちゃんねるでも、

「時代背景を考えりゃ当然だろ」
「もうなんでもクレームつけた者勝ちだよな」
「禁煙には賛成だが時代描写まで曲げろとは思わん」

など、普段煙草についていい印象を持っているわけではない層からも批判の嵐。「ネトウヨみたいな言い掛かりだな」という声まで出る始末である。

【参照リンク】
・映画「風立ちぬ」でのタバコの扱いについて(要望)
http://www.nosmoke55.jp/action/1308kazetatinu.html
・【映画】喫煙シーンが多い!? ジブリ『風立ちぬ』に日本禁煙学会が要望書・・・タバコの描写について苦言
http://www.logsoku.com/r/mnewsplus/1376459852/
・風立ちぬ(公式)
http://kazetachinu.jp/ 

■関連リンク
「健康対策」超熱心なニューヨーク、たばこ購入18歳 21歳に引き上げ構想発表 人々の反応は
ジェニファー、クリステン、オバマ...絶煙ツイート中のウーピー他、禁煙に成功したセレブ達!
イライジャ・ウッド『マニアック』 ニュージーランド上映禁止で大論争勃発! 

11 PHOTOS
東京都知事の石原慎太郎
See Gallery
「風立ちぬ」タバコの表現方法に日本禁煙学会が苦言 ネット「ネトウヨみたいな言い掛かり」

TOKYO - APRIL 5: Tokyo Governor Shintaro Ishihara smiles during his election campaign near Nerima Station on April 5, 2007 in Tokyo, Japan. The Tokyo gubernatorial election will  take place this weekend and Ishihara is running for his 3rd term.

COPENHAGEN, DENMARK - OCTOBER 02:  Tokyo governor and the city's Olympic bid committee leader Shintaro Ishihara attends the IOC members during the Tokyo 2016 presentation on October 2, 2009 at the Bella Centre in Copenhagen, Denmark. The 121st session of the International Olympic Committee (IOC) will vote on October 2 on whether Chicago, Tokyo, Rio de Janeiro or Madrid will host the 2016 Olympic Games.

LAUSANNE, SWITZERLAND - JUNE 17:  Tokyo 2016 Olympic bid President and Governor of Tokyo Shintaro Ishihara speaks to the press after presenting their bid to the IOC at the Olympic Museum on June 17, 2009 in Lausanne, Switzerland.

LUCERNE, SWITZERLAND - JUNE 16:  Tokyo 2016 Olympic bid President Shintaro Ishihara speaks to the press prior to there presentation bid and technical plans for the Olympic and Paralympic Games for 2016 on June 16, 2009 in Lucerne, Switzerland.

SEOUL, SOUTH KOREA - MAY 19:  Governor of Tokyo Shintaro Ishihara speaks during the C40 Large Cities Climate Summit Seoul 2009 at the Shilla Hotel on May 19, 2009 in Seoul, South Korea. Leaders of world's large cities will discuss to tackle climate changes and global warming in this four-day event.

TOKYO - JANUARY 13:  Tokyo Metropolitan Governor Shintaro Ishihara (C) speaks, along with (L-R) Tottori Governor Shinji Hirai, Niigata Governor Hirohiko Izumida, Saitama Governor Kiyoshi Ueda and Gunma Governor Masaaki Osawa, during a press conference held to discuss the formation of the 'Assembled Governors for the Return of Victims of Abduction by North Korea' at the Foreign Correspondents' Club of Japan on January 13, 2009 in Tokyo, Japan. It has been six years since five abductees returned home from North Korea, while the number of missing Japanese who might still be abducted in North Korea is estimated at more than 30.

TOKYO - NOVEMBER 27:  Tokyo Metropolitan Governor Shintaro Ishihara speaks at the reception party held by the Tokyo 2016 Bid Commitee at Ogasawara Hakushaku Tei on November 27, 2008 in Tokyo, Japan. Tokyo is among four candidates nominated to host 2016 summer Olympic Games.

TOKYO - JULY 28:  Tokyo Governor Shintaro Ishihara makes a speech during the Japan Olympic Team Send-Off Party at The Prince Park Tower on July 28, 2008 in Tokyo, Japan. Japan Olympic Committee will send 339 athletes to the Beijing 2008 Olympic Games in August.

TOKYO - APRIL 8: Governor of Tokyo Shintaro Ishihara raise hands celebrating at his election campaign office on April 8, 2007 in Tokyo, Japan. Ishihara won a third four-year term.

COPENHAGEN, DENMARK - OCTOBER 02:  Tokyo governor and the city's Olympic bid committee leader Shintaro Ishihara (R) and Chairman of the Japanese Olympic Commitee Ichiro Kono attend a press conference after  the Tokyo 2016 presentation on October 2, 2009 at the Bella Centre in Copenhagen, Denmark. The 121st session of the International Olympic Committee (IOC) will vote on October 2 on whether Chicago, Tokyo, Rio de Janeiro or Madrid will host the 2016 Olympic Games.

LAUSANNE, SWITZERLAND - JUNE 17:  Tokyo 2016 Olympic bid team (L-R) Shun-ichiro Okano, Chiharu Igaya, President Shintaro Ishihara, Vice-President Tsunekazu Takeda, Executive Board Member and CEO Ichiro Kono, Mikako Kotani, Shoichi Iwadate, Toshiaki Hosaka pose together after presenting their bid to the IOC at the Olympic Museum on June 17, 2009 in Lausanne, Switzerland.

HIDE CAPTION
SHOW CAPTION
of
すべて見る
スライドに戻る

20 PHOTOS
誤解されがちなバンド名20選
See Gallery
「風立ちぬ」タバコの表現方法に日本禁煙学会が苦言 ネット「ネトウヨみたいな言い掛かり」
HIDE CAPTION
SHOW CAPTION
of
すべて見る
スライドに戻る

13 PHOTOS
『雪花と秘文字の扇』プレミア
See Gallery
「風立ちぬ」タバコの表現方法に日本禁煙学会が苦言 ネット「ネトウヨみたいな言い掛かり」

NEW YORK, NY - JULY 13:  Sir Ben Kingsley attends the Cinema Society with Ivanka Trump Jewelry & Diane Von Furstenberg screening of "Snow Flower And The Secret Fan" at the Tribeca Grand Hotel on July 13, 2011 in New York City.

NEW YORK, NY - JULY 13:  Actress Gabourey Sidibe attends the Cinema Society with Ivanka Trump Jewelry & Diane Von Furstenberg screening of "Snow Flower And The Secret Fan" at the Tribeca Grand Hotel on July 13, 2011 in New York City.

NEW YORK, NY - JULY 13:  Model Irina Shayk attends the Cinema Society with Ivanka Trump Jewelry & Diane Von Furstenberg screening of "Snow Flower And The Secret Fan" at the Tribeca Grand Hotel on July 13, 2011 in New York City.

NEW YORK, NY - JULY 13:  Ivanka Trump and Jared Kushner attend the Cinema Society with Ivanka Trump Jewelry & Diane Von Furstenberg screening of "Snow Flower And The Secret Fan" at the Tribeca Grand Hotel on July 13, 2011 in New York City.

NEW YORK, NY - JULY 13:  Actress Lucy Liu attends the Cinema Society with Ivanka Trump Jewelry & Diane Von Furstenberg screening of "Snow Flower And The Secret Fan" at the Tribeca Grand Hotel on July 13, 2011 in New York City.

NEW YORK, NY - JULY 13:  NYC Mayor Michael Bloomberg and producer Florence Sloan attend the Cinema Society with Ivanka Trump Jewelry & Diane Von Furstenberg screening of "Snow Flower And The Secret Fan" at the Tribeca Grand Hotel on July 13, 2011 in New York City.

NEW YORK, NY - JULY 13:  Actresses Nicole Kidman and Li Bingbing attend the Cinema Society with Ivanka Trump Jewelry & Diane Von Furstenberg screening of "Snow Flower And The Secret Fan" at the Tribeca Grand Hotel on July 13, 2011 in New York City.

NEW YORK, NY - JULY 13:  Actress Nora Zehetner attends the Cinema Society with Ivanka Trump Jewelry & Diane Von Furstenberg screening of "Snow Flower And The Secret Fan" at the Tribeca Grand Hotel on July 13, 2011 in New York City.

NEW YORK, NY - JULY 13:  Actress Olivia Munn attends the Cinema Society with Ivanka Trump Jewelry & Diane Von Furstenberg screening of "Snow Flower And The Secret Fan" at the Tribeca Grand Hotel on July 13, 2011 in New York City.

NEW YORK, NY - JULY 13: Author Lisa See, director  Wayne Wange, Nicole Kidman, Li Bingbing producer  Wendi Murdoch, Deborra-Lee Furness and producer  Florence Sloan attend the Cinema Society with Ivanka Trump Jewelry & Diane Von Furstenberg screening of "Snow Flower And The Secret Fan" at the Tribeca Grand Hotel on July 13, 2011 in New York City.

Director Wayne Wang attends a special screening of 'Snow Flower and the Secret Fan' hosted by the Cinema Society at the Tribeca Grand Hotel on Wednesday, July 13, 2011 in New York.

NEW YORK, NY - JULY 13:  Producer Wendi Murdoch and founder of The Cinema Society Andrew Saffir attend The Cinema Society with Ivanka Trump Jewelry & Diane Von Furstenberg screening of "Snow Flower And The Secret Fan" at the Tribeca Grand Hotel on July 13, 2011 in New York City.

NEW YORK, NY - JULY 13:  Singer/musician Keith Urban and wife actress Nicole Kidman attend the Cinema Society with Ivanka Trump Jewelry & Diane Von Furstenberg screening of "Snow Flower And The Secret Fan" at the Tribeca Grand Hotel on July 13, 2011 in New York City.

HIDE CAPTION
SHOW CAPTION
of
すべて見る
スライドに戻る

12 PHOTOS
Madonna MDNA Tour: Opening Night in Tel Aviv, Israel
See Gallery
「風立ちぬ」タバコの表現方法に日本禁煙学会が苦言 ネット「ネトウヨみたいな言い掛かり」

Madonna MDNA Tour: Opening Night in Tel Aviv, Israel (May 31, 2012)

Madonna MDNA Tour: Opening Night in Tel Aviv, Israel (May 31, 2012)

Madonna MDNA Tour: Opening Night in Tel Aviv, Israel (May 31, 2012)

Madonna MDNA Tour: Opening Night in Tel Aviv, Israel (May 31, 2012)

Madonna MDNA Tour: Opening Night in Tel Aviv, Israel (May 31, 2012)

Madonna MDNA Tour: Opening Night in Tel Aviv, Israel (May 31, 2012)

Madonna MDNA Tour: Opening Night in Tel Aviv, Israel (May 31, 2012)

Madonna MDNA Tour: Opening Night in Tel Aviv, Israel (May 31, 2012)

Madonna MDNA Tour: Opening Night in Tel Aviv, Israel (May 31, 2012)

Madonna MDNA Tour: Opening Night in Tel Aviv, Israel (May 31, 2012)

Madonna MDNA Tour: Opening Night in Tel Aviv, Israel (May 31, 2012)

Madonna MDNA Tour: Opening Night in Tel Aviv, Israel (May 31, 2012)

HIDE CAPTION
SHOW CAPTION
of
すべて見る
スライドに戻る

44 PHOTOS
ベネディクト・カンバーバッチ来日会見【フォト集】
See Gallery
「風立ちぬ」タバコの表現方法に日本禁煙学会が苦言 ネット「ネトウヨみたいな言い掛かり」
HIDE CAPTION
SHOW CAPTION
of
すべて見る
スライドに戻る
続きを読む